“我们的词汇那么贫乏了吗? 需要法语才能表达我们的观点?” 引用电影中的台词,之所以用法语,是因为法语的使用绕不开阶层和品味。
大市民的品味是bourgeois,gossip girls是nouveau riche。谁能料到同样的描写曼哈顿的preppy,十几年变化那么大了。大市民一直讨论阶层的落寞,一定程度上是的,正如这些孩子说的,向下移动很容易,想想gossip girls表现的阶层,靠时装(主要是品牌)和炫耀性消费,的确阶层向下移动了。
整部电影主要是对话和简单的场景交替,是不是和简奥斯丁小说很一致。女主Audrey也有着奥斯丁小说人物般的个性和价值。Bourgeois的品味,比如爱好文学性的讨论和对哲学的思考,以架起一个haute bourgeoisie,的确在现在慢慢被取代,随着美国中产的萎缩,这个阶层也在被稀释。如果这个电影在30年后的今天拍,似乎没人能相信了,gossip girls需要的是快速的性爱和金钱带来的满足,但是一个人你和他聊哲学,文学然后发现你慢慢爱上他,会被说成是知识分子的意淫。所以我还是很偏爱这部电影,借用电影的话,“奥斯丁的价值在现在会被嬉笑。” “奥斯丁那时候也会嘲笑我们现在的价值呢。”
想想大学时光匆匆过了,是否还有人和你思考社会,哲学吗?
Make-believe posing and posturing is part and parcel of acting, professionals need years of practice to excel in it, for amateurs who tread the boards for the very first time (METROPOLITAN is a case in point), the result can be a toss-up and to a great extent contingent on its director’s aptitude to key their personal traits into the roles they are assigned to play, in that regard, Whit Stillman makes an exemplar specimen with his very first feature film, a less neurotic, more self-possessed leisure-class confab-fest a là Woody Allen.
Set in the present day of Manhattan’s debutante season circa Christmas time, a secluded group of Upper East State preppies, the so-called “Sally Fowler Rat Pack”, welcomes an initiate named Tom Townsend (Clements), a Princeton student who is a rung lower than the rest, among which Audrey Rouget (Farina) has been secretly carrying a torch for him, but Tom still hasn’t got over his popular ex-girlfriend Serena (Thompson), who is not included in the group though, and prioritizes the latter over Audrey during one outing, which causes some dissension among the rat pack, that aside, Tom is gradually eased into the group by a cynical Nick Smith (Eigeman), whose snarky remarks about a young titled baron Rick Von Sloneker (Kempe), do not strike the right chord with other members of the group, particularly Cynthia (Gillies), and he starts to lose his credit after fabulating a harrowing story to authenticate Rick’s womanizing vice. After giving some introspection of his own actions, and parsing his true feelings for Audrey, a guileless Tom dreads that he has obliquely driven her into the arms of Rick, as a last resort, accompanied by the philosophy-obsessed Charlie Black (Nichols), he drops by Rick’s beach house to rescue Audrey, only to find out that Audrey isn’t a clueless damsel-in-distress, thankfully, his heroic gesture seems to work in his favor at any rate.
Enfolded in a beguilingly vintage, subdued golden hue and jazz-infused incidental music, METROPOLITAN ages resplendently well with its sophisticated candor and stimulating burrowing into the mentation of a certain cross-section, which doesn’t necessarily pall into neither undue self-aggrandizement, self-absorption, nor self-lamentation (either ways has killed the mumblecore fad by now), each and every character is sedulously designed with a rounded representation like a real-life person with both charms and defects (although their ratio varies drastically from individual to individual), Audrey’s bashful nature cannot blot out a bracing mixed whiff of self-sufficiency and fragile sensibility (rubbed off from Jane Austen’s novels for sure), Tom has a boyish innocuousness that is very congenial, but his own wet-behind-the-ear, insular cognition of the vast world is troublesome for his age, and indeed, they do make a compatible and complementary couple.
Nichols flogs Charlie’s pedantic verbiage to death with both barrels, but also betrays his pedantic geekiness with an aroma of benign openness, but it is Eigeman, who stands out among the entire ensemble with a telegenic patina that is few and far between for a tenderfoot, who is able to telegraph that unpretentious feeling of being brutally honest, yet synchronically struts his character’s off-putting self-righteousness, a fascinating performance which leaves Nick sorely missed after his symbolic departure at the train station in the wee hours, therein the proto-bromance between Nick and Tom is acutely pointed and artfully downplayed at once by Stillman, who magnificently breaks his duck with an authorial signature, notwithstanding it is predominantly seen through an unbalanced lens of a boy’s club.
referential entries: Stillman’s THE LAST DAYS OF DISCO (1996, 7.0/10); LOVE AND FRIENDSHIP (2016, 7.2/10).
版权归作者所有,任何形式转载请联系作者。 作者:FrozenElsa(来自豆瓣) 来源://www.douban.com/doubanapp/dispatch?uri=/note/603893378/ 因为之前不认识她,看完之后真的被迷的不要不要的,所以查了好多资料。但是得到的结果都是心碎💔 她演这片前是在梅西百货做销售员,可惜的是演完之后依然是销售员。。 当时评论界给的很高的评价,不管是给这片,还是给她,甚至有新奥黛丽赫本的评价。但是好莱坞好像不是很钟意她,在这部之后又演了三部片后就息影了,其中包括马丁斯科塞斯的纯真年代,当然,是个小角色,以及依然是斯蒂尔曼的最后的迪斯科(我真的没看到她。。。) 看了大市民25周年的那个采访,料挺足,2015年的,看到她和导演都老了不少,反正我是认不出她现在的样子了,她有说到为什么拍完这部片后就没有什么片约。原因有点。。奇怪,不懂是玩笑还是真的。。她说因为她不是金发,所以没什么片约。。应该是玩笑吧。。不过我愿意相信这个是真的。。 果然征服了评论界,还是依然容易在好莱坞翻船的啊。。真是太可惜了
Conservatism with a small c
雅痞清谈片,喜欢每一个室内戏之间的专场镜头,曼哈顿街头的怀旧暖意。
2016.8.4重看。当年居然傻傻写了个很糟糕的长评。喜欢都市空镜头,人物的对话实在是啰嗦而可笑呢。比如男主说自己从来不读小说,只读文学评论。所有这些啰嗦愚蠢的对话,讲的都是傻傻的青春和爱情。
传达时代精神的作品,典型的CC口味。Whit Stillman相对客观地展现了上世纪的雅痞风潮,但总的来说还是没有跳出自己的阶级身份,以至略显保守。
模仿伍迪艾伦,非职业的演员比较自然。
《绯闻女孩》遇上《安妮·霍尔》,这帮少男少女再过四十年可以直接移步伍迪艾伦片场了。形似《早餐俱乐部》,但思想内核相差甚远。本片终究还是纽约上东区那些被宠坏了的富家孩子无所事事夸夸其谈的装B日常,加上了一个也相当虚伪的outsider,说明虚荣伪善不分穷富哈。可是啊,少了伍迪艾伦自带的幽默自嘲和灵性转折,本片还是略显得冗长无趣了些。
所有混圈(juan)的人都能或多或少找到一丝影子;彼此曾有一段人生交叉,在牛皮、八卦、诽谤、空谈诸如此类文青擅长并爱好的高级游戏中渐渐脱离青涩。
被迷到了,讽刺、深刻洞察和中产阶级的角色分明就是青春版伍迪艾伦,曼哈顿上流圈子青年的苦恼和迷茫、早熟和天真并存的性格在一次次聚会的唠叨话语中展现,角色越发可爱,非职业演员们的细节把握异常出色,导演显然功不可没。结尾萌得要死。
真的和大一时的生活太像了,一帮子Urban Haute Bourgeosie出来的学生整天就在吃喝玩乐玩真心话大冒险外加唱K,表面上都是朋友背地里发展着不知道多少角的复杂恋爱关系。一年后大家都玩腻所有友情也都变味,大家各奔东西。90年代美国UHB的生活就是现在中国UHB的写照。
中产阶级审慎魅力 90年代的复古锵锵五人行 社交生活之于美国新青年的必要性 我们是太不把自己当回事儿还是太把自己当回事儿了 Whit Stillman的城市三部曲针针见血
为神马我看这片时总会想到逼组?+10086!!!
Pythonmania汽车大师 2009-09-02: totally allenish,那个神经质larry就是照着伍爷模板来的 我在电视上看的,光听配乐和对白就以为是我从前漏了没看的哪部Woody Allen。
大都市的学生向往中产阶级生活,一个又一个的小团体聚会。切入点不错,过多的对白有点无聊。
东区的你担心裙子穿起来不合身被人笑话,西区的我着急今天不退掉租来的礼服又要多付25美元;东区的你说冬天人人穿着大衣的样子让人想起《战争与和平》,西区的我说深有同感但还没看过那本书;东区的你让我开始读奥斯汀,西区的我让你认识了傅立叶. 哈哈,最后三个人傻乎乎的走在回扭腰的路上冷成狗,真是可爱。朋友这种事和爱情一样,强求不来的,只有真的同道中人才能走到最后。啊~ 年轻的UHB
Whit Stillman 的作品确实会让热你联想起伍迪艾伦,艾伦做的喜剧会更加夸张和讽刺,但他的群戏并不多见,镜头的调度能力也不高,文本性更重。Stillman则比较好的平衡了对话和影像,兼有批判和讽刺幽默。
totally allenish,那个神经质larry就是照着伍爷模板来的
没字幕有三分之一的时间你都不知道他们在说什么...哲学,社会,文学,时政,命运...一部几乎只有对白的电影...忒文艺了,只有一点有感受,就是再好的朋友圈子也会因为追逐自己的生活而分散...Nick演的真好
“相对文学本身,我更喜欢文学批评”,哈哈!这部电影简直太可爱了。5/Park Ave.的富家公子小姐们的圣诞假期是一个又一个聚会,他们渴望变成大人,进入他们的世界,同时又有自己的批判和迷茫,当然还有年轻人特有的青涩和最纯真的互相吸引… 愿每个奥黛丽都找到自己的汤姆<3
没想到蛮浪漫的,怀着玩心去贯彻资产阶级的平庸趣味,实则还是年轻学生们一贯的谈人生谈理想谈哲学文学什么的,Whit Stillman总能从最庸俗处发掘出一些真善美的小思考,挺好
许多cast后来又参演Last Days of Disco,成熟的话题中透着青涩